HTC TyTN vs Sony Ericsson P990i
// December 30th, 2006 // 23 Comments » // Tech

Funny how something like a blog actually captures exactly what you felt and thought in the past (guess that’s the reason we blog, to create a journal of sorts?). Anyhow, it’s almost two years to the day that I had to decide on which new cellphone to choose for my contract renewal. So here I am again, trying to decide which of the new phones I will be stuck with for the next 24-months.
This process obviously began months ago (June in fact), with the news of the new Sony Ericsson P990i due for our shores. Feverishly, many have been anticipating it’s arrival and release to the various cellphone shops around the country and finally being able to hold and see it up close and personal.
I thought my mind was made up. How wrong I was.
Enter stage left, the HTC TyTN, which by the looks of the advertising and hype is bound to take the market by storm. It certainly has the credentials, having won a handfull of smartphone of the year awards. That means something, right?
It sports almost every type of connectivity one could possibly need:
GPRS Class 10 – 32 – 48 kbps
EDGE Class 10 – 236.8 kbps
3G HSDPA – 1.8 Mbps
WLAN Wi-Fi – 802.11b/g
Bluetooth – Yes
Infrared – Yes
USB – Yes
Importantly it also has a touchscreen, QWERTY-keyboard and 2-Megapixel camera – all non-negotiable features as a miminum for me.
On the downside, probably the only thing I could find that really bugged me was battery life – Stand-by up to 200 hours and talk time up to 5 hours. In comparison with the P990i, it was the only one of two things that the Sony Ericsson had better stats on – Stand-by up to 400 hours and talk time up to 9 hours. But these things will probably stand in a cradle during the day – so a charge shouldn’t be such a big problem (right?).
I double-checked online comparisons from GSMArena, All About Symbian and Bengalboy‘s very thorough ‘shootout’ between the two.
So who really needs a RDS Radio and HSCSD connectivity (SE P990i) when you have EDGE, Wifi in 802.11 b and g and a 4-times faster HSDPA (TyTN)?
Reviews (see previous links) mention that the P990i sucks a bit in the memory department with frequent “spontaneous” restarts, while the TyTN gets a thumbs-down for not including memory (those dinky microSD cards) in the box.
Bollocks, damn, damn, damn. Now what do I choose? HELP!










